Source: Express money
Junk the jeweller, bung the bank. If you buy gold for investment purposes, you don’t need to look beyond gold funds now ..
When the new fund offer of Gold Benchmark Exchange Traded Scheme opens for subscription on Thursday, it will mark a milestone in Indian investing. Not only will it mark the debut of a hassle-free way of investing in gold, it will make India only the seventh country in the world to offer gold funds to its investing public. If you buy gold for investment purposes, not for consumption, take note: gold funds are the least problematic and most cost-efficient way of investing in the yellow metal.
Gold BeES
It’s fitting that the first gold fund to hit the market should be from Benchmark Asset Management Company, which filed an offer document for a gold exchange-traded fund (ETF) with Sebi as far back as May 2002 the first to do so not just in India, but also in the world. UTI Mutual Fund and Kotak Mahindra Mutual Fund have also got the green signal from Sebi to launch their gold funds. These are expected to be launched any day now and will probably be on the same lines as Benchmark’s Gold ETF.
Gold BeES is an open-ended ETF that gives you an exposure to gold, without you holding gold in the physical form. Here’s how it will work. In its NFO, two kinds of units will be allotted. The money pooled in by investors like you will be used to buy gold from companies and high net worth individuals, who will, in turn, be allotted ‘creation units’. The gold will be stored by a custodian on Benchmark’s behalf.
The transaction cost in a gold fund is 1-1.5%. A jeweller charges a mark-up of 5-7%, banks 10-20%The creation units give these large investors the right to buy gold from Benchmark whenever they want. The gold serves as the underlying security backing your units. So, when the price of gold rises or falls, the value of Benchmark’s gold holding moves in tandem, as does the NAV (net asset value) of your units. Once the allotment happens, the fund is listed. The units allotted to you (not the creation units) are traded on a stock exchange like any other security.
The trading price is closely linked to the fund’s NAV, which is closely linked to the price of gold. Each unit of Gold BeES will represent one gram of gold. Say, the per gram price of gold on the date of allotment is Rs 950 and you invest Rs 10,000, the minimum. Benchmark is charging an entry load of 1.5 per cent (Rs 150 on Rs 10,000). That means the net amount invested is Rs 9,850. Given the price of Rs 950 per gram, you will be allotted 10.37 units (9,850/950). These units are like a company’s shares, and will trade on stock exchanges. So, when you want to sell your units, in part or in full, you sell it on the exchange at the given market price. Similarly, when you want to buy more units, you buy more from the stock exchange. Since the market price will be linked to the spot price of gold at all times, you have a near-mirror exposure to the asset. Says Rajan Mehta, executive director, Benchmark Asset Management Company: “Since we don’t have an official spot rate in India, we have benchmarked it against LBMA bullion rates, to which we add import duties and VAT, and convert it to Rupees.”
There can be times when this linkage weakens a surge in demand for units lead to a spike in the market price of the Gold BeES or a sell-off leads to a crash. Benchmark has budgeted for such times also. It has tied up with some authorised participants who, in such times, will arbitrage between spot price of gold and the market price of the Gold BeES, and link prices again to NAV. As a result, the deviation in the market price from the NAV is expected to be minimal.
The advantages
Gold ETFs are, by far, a cheaper and hassle-free way of investing in gold, compared to jewellery, bars and coins, more so if you invest only a small sum. Lower cost. In Gold BeES, the transaction cost in the NFO is the entry load (1.5 per cent). By comparison, a jeweller charges 5-7 per cent over the spot price, banks 10-20 per cent. In fact, experts say, if you get top brokerage rates, you can even invest in a gold ETF for less than 1.5 per cent through the secondary market. Says financial planner Surya Bhatia: “Investors are buying and selling on 0.6 per cent brokerage. Even if you add some arbitrage spread to that, it will be less than the 1.5 per cent.”
Then, there’s the recurring charge. Benchmark will charge an annual expense of up to 1 per cent, which will go out of the NAV. Even this might come down. Says Mehta: “As the size grows, we hope to reduce it.” If you hold gold in the physical form, you will need to rent a locker, the annual charge for which varies from Rs 400 for a small one to Rs 4,000 for a big one. If you are a HNI and have a sizeable gold holding, it works in your favour. But if you are a marginal investor, ETFs make more sense.
Greater convenience. You will hold Gold BeES as an electronic entry in your demat account. You don’t have to worry about purity, storage or safety (that’s Benchmark’s job). All this without compromising on liquidity. Although ETFs are still gaining currency, trading volumes in existing stock-based ETFs is high enough to facilitate easy entry and exit for small investors. Gold BeES, being the first of its kind in India and with obvious advantages, should see strong investor interest.
Lower taxes. Gold held in physical form is subject to a wealth tax, of 1 per cent of the incremental amount above Rs 15 lakh. So, if you have gold worth Rs 20 lakh, you will have to pay a wealth tax of Rs 5,000 (1 per cent of Rs 5 lakh). Gold funds are exempt from wealth tax. There is a differential tax treatment of long-term capital gains the threshold for physical funds is three years, but one year for gold funds.
Should you invest?
It depends on your investment objective. Remember, though gold has done well in the past few years and is expected to appreciate further (See box: Still a golden run, page 1), that doesn’t make it an automatic investment choice or the cornerstone of a portfolio. Gold is different from conventional financial assets like debt and equity. Says Bhatia: “Gold is a store of value and a hedge in turbulent times, not a wealth-creation investment vehicle.” If you are looking to give your portfolio a defensive tilt, gold is a good option and gold funds the best way to get that exposure.
The shine will stay
Madan Sabnavis
It is interesting that gold has been a traditional form of savings in India based on the gut feeling that its price can never fall. With the growth of futures trading, new investment options have been offered; and the proposed launch of gold ETFs is a further improvement, where you can trade on gold, without holding it and yet be sure that there is a gold backing for every transaction. Today, gold is also a very smart investment option, and there are a number of theories that indicate the direction of price movement.
Gold is today priced in the range of $650/ounce. The Indian price is a mirror reflection of the international price adjusting for the rupee-dollar rate and the taxes levied at the Central and state levels. The correlation coefficient how closely domestic gold prices track international prices is a high 95 per cent. So, if we get the international price movement right, we will get the Indian price right.
There are three factors to watch for depending on the investment horizon in mind. In the very short run, which could be up to three months, the market links the price of gold to the price of oil. Typically, when the price of oil goes up, so does that of gold. The price of crude has been falling in the past two months, but the feeling is that as winter sets in the US, it could start rising. And so would the price of gold then.
In the short run, say up to six months, inflation will be a dominant factor affecting the price of gold, which is considered to be a natural hedge against inflation. Inflation appeared to be a worry in the Western world, as there was signs of an overheated global recovery, which made several central banks raise their interest rates. However, since the US Fed or other central banks have not raised interest rates in the recent past, it may be concluded that inflation is not an immediate concern.
In the longer run, which can be defined as one year, the price of gold will be linked inversely with the price of the dollar. This has been historically the case, except for a brief deviation in the latter part of 2005, when all asset prices went up, including the dollar. The correlation coefficient here is over 85 per cent.
Now, with the US current account deficit at 6.3 per cent, the dollar has to depreciate. It did happen by about 8 per cent last year, falling from $1.20/euro to $1.30/euro. However, there will be certain mitigating factors such as pressure from within the US to correct this deficit through higher interest rates, as well as from outside, particularly the Euro zone, which will be keen to ensure that its currency does not strengthen too much so as to blunt its export competitiveness.
Putting all these three factors together, only an upward movement can be visualised, albeit with a crawl given the mitigating circumstances. Lastly, with gold ETFs coming into play, there will be greater demand for the physical metal too, which will exert an upward pressure on prices. In short, the fundamentals indicate that the bull run in gold should continue in the current year.
The writer is chief economist, NCDEX. The views expressed are personal
‘Costs are not high’
Rajan Mehta, Executive director, Benchmark Asset Management Company
It’s appropriate that the country’s first gold fund is floated by Benchmark Asset Management Company. Almost five years, Benchmark had submitted an offer document with Sebi for the world’s first gold exchange-traded fund (ETF). Benchmark ED Rajan Mehta on its finer points.
How will you classify your gold ETF?It’s a passive fund with underlying assets to it. Its NAV moves in tandem with the spot price of gold. Since we don’t have an official spot rate in India, we have benchmarked it against LBMA bullion rates, to which we add import duties and VAT, and convert it to Rupees. Since your holding is in a demat account, not physical, it is a convenient, transparent and tax-efficient mode of investing.
Isn’t the NFO entry load of 1.5 per cent high?Not really. It’s comparable with the secondary market transaction costs, which comprise 0.5-0.85 per cent of invetsment as brokerage and a bid-ask spread of 0.50 percentage point.
And expenses of 1 per cent a year?Internationally, it ranges from 0.4-1 per cent. Here, the custodian charge alone is around 0.5 percentage point, which is high. But as the size grows, we hope to reduce the management cost.
Is gold a good investment?Gold is a store of value. It’s a unique asset and appeals to all sections. A farmer in a village is interested in it, as are central banks. It shouldn’t be taken as a return-generating asset, but as a store of value.
What is the challenge for you?Right now, people don’t understand ETFs. The challenge is to make people understand the product and penetrate the market, and then innovate with the product.
‘Don’t buy for returns’
Surya Bhatia, Financial Planner
One of the things financial planners never tire of saying is that gold is a hedge against all calamities, not an investment avenue for wealth creation. It's a theme that Surya Bhatia iterates again when asked how the small investor should look at gold ETFs as an investment option.
How do you rate gold as an investment?Gold is a comletely different asset class than, say, debt or equities. It is a good hedge, but it shouldn't be seen as a return-generating asset.
It helps you preserve the value of your asset. If you are looking for returns, gold is not for you.
If one is not looking for returns, is the Gold ETF a good option?No, it isn’t. But if you have to invest in gold, it should be the ETF way, as it has many advantages. The ETF doesn't require you to physically possess gold. Also, the cost of transaction and ownership is less than other options. Therefore, I see it becoming a popular mode of investment.
And how do you rate the Benchmark BeES?The product is good, but it could have been better with a lower entry load and annual charge. The entry load, at 1.5 per cent of the investment amount, seems to be on the higher side.
If you purchase those units from the secondary market, your transaction cost, which comprise the brokerage cost and the arbitrage spread, would work out to around 1 per cent of your investment. At 1 per cent per year, the annual expense also seems to be on the higher side, and can be brought down.
So, what would you advise investors?Rather than invest in the new fund offer (NFO), wait for a month for the units to list, and then invest.